How does a background check play into the hiring process?

“I got the job” is usually one of the big moments that stand out in a candidate’s mind. However, as big as that moment may be for a candidate and HR, we know it takes a lot of time and labor to hire the perfect fit for the organization and position. At times, the hiring process can feel like a limitless number of tasks, due diligence, emails, and paperwork. So where does the background check fit into this picture?

The hiring process can vary based on the employer, their internal processes, and the sensitive nature of the position. After screening of applications/resumes and initial telephone screens, usually a few in-person/web-based interviews are the next step in the process. Many employers process some level of a “background check” on candidates as part of the hiring process, but this is usually done post-selection, interview(s), and tentative offer. Several states have specific laws regarding when the background check can be initiated, ie: post-offer, post-interview, etc. The tentative offer will usually be contingent on the employer’s defined parameters and policy. Federal or state governments may impose additional requirements in certain sectors, as well. These parameters could include both internal and outsourced screening, including reference checks, education, or employment verifications, physical, drug test, and some type of criminal background check, along with what could be many other employer-based variables. Once these tasks and screening are complete, hire, orientation, and training dates are usually set.

From the beginning to the end of the process it can be extremely time-consuming, for both the employer and employee. Applicants should be as thorough as possible when providing information to either their potential employer or the screening company. Again, based on the background check level being processed it can take some time. Applicants should review their information and provide updated, accurate and thorough data. This small task will speed up the process considerably. An example, applicants notifying references and verifying their current number and email address. This can do two things, prepare the reference for an unexpected third-party contact, and make sure the supplied information is current. Candidates supplying a full middle name to help weed out possible criminal records, is again another example of why thorough information is key.

Employers should communicate the process and expectations to the applicant. Lack of communication causes delays and confusion. Be sure your candidates know what to expect, a step-by-step guide or general email can be extremely helpful. Be sure to educate yourself on the process, even if your organization outsources portions of your on-boarding process. General overall knowledge can allow for a greater understanding of the process and be cognizant of any areas that may need improvement. Finally, be sure to let the applicant know if there is an issue, how it can be fixed or exactly what they can do to address the problem. If you called a former employer and received a bad reference, do not leave the candidate guessing that they failed another part of the process. HR’s indifferent response or lack thereof can leave a bad view of your organization, or your processes with the candidate.

Picture of Brittany Bollinger Boyle

Brittany Bollinger Boyle

With over 13 years of working expertise in the background screening industry, Brittany Bollinger Boyle is the dynamic CEO and Founder of AB Global. Often referred to as the “youngest old-timer” in the industry, Brittany’s career journey started early when she attended the inaugural National Association of Professional Background Screeners (NAPBS now PBSA) conference at just 12 years old. This early exposure sparked a passion that has driven her to become a leading figure in the field, with a deep understanding of the industry’s evolution.

Subscribe To Our Blog

More Blog Posts

Most people understand that background screening is a critical component of the hiring process, yet many HR professionals lack a clear understanding of how background screens are conducted and what they should expect from screening providers. One reason for this is that over the years background screening providers have become increasingly opaque about these details, which allows for more leeway to manipulate service offerings and pricing, and quite frankly, to cut corners.
Remote interviews have become a cornerstone of the hiring process, offering convenience, flexibility, and the ability to connect with top talent across geographic boundaries. However, remote interviewing presents unique challenges that require thoughtful planning and execution to ensure a smooth and effective process. Here are some best practices to help you conduct successful remote interviews that provide a positive candidate experience and lead to well-informed hiring decisions.
The background screening industry was once a pillar of trust and diligence, ensuring that companies could make informed hiring decisions with confidence. But over time, standards have eroded. The industry has devolved as companies prioritized speed and cost-cutting over accuracy and integrity.